Rum from our Highland, NY shop, from silver and gold to dark, spiced and rhum agricole. Reserve online and pick it up at our counter on Route 44/55, usually ready in about 15 minutes.
Lucky Horseshoe Wine & Liquors is the wine and liquor store at 591 US-44 #55 in Highland, NY, serving the Hudson Valley. Narrow these bottles by price, bottle size, country, region or vintage, and limit the list to bottles in stock to see what is on the shelf today.
Pickup is the only way we fill orders — we do not deliver. We email you when the order is placed and again when it is ready. Bring a government-issued photo ID: New York law requires us to check the date of birth on every alcohol sale, and the person who placed the order collects it. You pay at the register when you pick up.
16 of 44 available for pickupClear all
Silver Rum · 47% ABV · Barbados
$33.99750 mL · $45.32/L
Fruit-infused Rum · 40% ABV · Barbados
$37.991 L · $37.99/L
Not available for pickup right now. Call (845) 834-2024 to check the shelf.
Dark Rum · 80% ABV · Saint Croix, United States · 750 mL
XO Rum · 40% ABV · Demerara, Guyana · 750 mL
XO Rum · Barbados · 750 mL
Black Rum · Bermuda · 1 L
Small-batch Rum · 55% ABV · Venezuela · 700 mL
Small-batch Rum · 55% ABV · Barbados · 750 mL
Silver Rum · Jalisco, Mexico · 750 mL
Rhum Agricole · 49% ABV · Haiti · 750 mL
Amber Rum · 40% ABV · Puerto Rico · 375 mL
Amber Rum · 40% ABV · Puerto Rico · 1 L
Amber Rum · 40% ABV · Puerto Rico · 1.75 L
Spiced Rum · Jamaica · 1.75 L
Spiced Rum · Jamaica · 375 mL
Spiced Rum · Jamaica · 1 L
Flavored Rum · Saint Croix, United States · 1 L
Flavored Rum · Saint Croix, United States · 1 L
Silver Rum · Puerto Rico · 375 mL
Gold Rum · Puerto Rico · 375 mL
Black Rum · Bermuda · 750 mL
Black Rum · Jamaica · 750 mL
Amber Rum · Barbados · 1 L
Amber Rum · Barbados · 750 mL
Dark Rum · Jamaica · 1 L
XO Rum · Fiji · 750 mL
XO Rum · Martinique · 700 mL
XO Rum · Dominican Republic · 750 mL
Spiced Rum · 40% ABV · Saint Lucia · 700 mL
Arrival estimate unavailable
Too little history to estimate delivery reliability History: past 365 days.
Dark Rum · 54.5% ABV · Jamaica · 1 L