Closed now — opens today at 11:00 AM

Category
Specials
Pickup
Rewards

(845) 834-2024

ESC

Quick Search
- Wine↵
- Liquor
- Deals & Specials
- Staff Picks

↑↓navigate↵selectescclose

Type to search products, pages, and settings. Results and suggestions update automatically as you type.

Red Wine
White Wine
Sparkling
Rosé
Whiskey
Tequila
Vodka
Gin
Rum
Liqueur

Whiskey

Rye Whiskey

Our Story
In-Store Pickup
Blog
Contact
Near Rocking Horse Ranch

Store information

Lucky Horseshoe Wine & Liquors

591 US-44 #55, Highland, NY 12528

(845) 834-2024

Hours

Closed now — opens today at 11:00 AM

Mon – Fri: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Saturday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Sunday: 12:00 PM – 5:00 PM

Must be 21+ to purchase alcohol. Please drink responsibly.

Licensed by the New York State Liquor Authority (NYSLA). Marlboro Wines and Liquors Inc. · Liquor Store License #0100-26-247611. View License

Red Wine
White Wine
Sparkling
Rosé
Whiskey
Tequila
Vodka
Gin
Rum
Liqueur

Whiskey

Rye Whiskey

Sort

1 of 2 available for pickupUnited States Clear all

Browse

All bottles
Wine282 of 815 available for pickup
Spirits190 of 472 available for pickup
Other
- Cocktail Bitters0 of 6 available for pickup
- RTD11 of 24 available for pickup

Availability

Available for pickup only1

Price

$25 to $502

Size

1 L1

Country

United States

United States2

Region in United States

Indiana1
Kentucky1

Brand

Starlight Distillery1
Witches' Tree Kentucky1

Features

Organic, none available
Vegan, none available
Gluten-free3

Available for pickup · 1

Starlight Distillery 'Old Rickhouse' Straight Rye Whiskey
Rye Whiskey · 46% ABV · Indiana, United States
$34.99750 mL

Also in our collection · 1

Not available for pickup right now. Call (845) 834-2024 to check the shelf.

Witches' Tree Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey
Rye Whiskey · 48% ABV · Kentucky, United States · 1 L
1 L$39.99

1 of 2 available for pickupUnited States Clear all

Browse

All bottles
Wine282 of 815 available for pickup
Spirits190 of 472 available for pickup
Other
- Cocktail Bitters0 of 6 available for pickup
- RTD11 of 24 available for pickup

Availability

Available for pickup only1

Price

$25 to $502

Size

1 L1

Country

United States

United States2

Region in United States

Indiana1
Kentucky1

Brand

Starlight Distillery1
Witches' Tree Kentucky1

Features

Organic, none available
Vegan, none available
Gluten-free3

Available for pickup · 1

Starlight Distillery 'Old Rickhouse' Straight Rye Whiskey
Rye Whiskey · 46% ABV · Indiana, United States
$34.99750 mL

Also in our collection · 1

Not available for pickup right now. Call (845) 834-2024 to check the shelf.

Witches' Tree Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey
Rye Whiskey · 48% ABV · Kentucky, United States · 1 L
1 L$39.99

Rye Whiskey

Scotch Whisky

Sour Mash

Available for pickup · 1

Starlight Distillery 'Old Rickhouse' Straight Rye Whiskey

Also in our collection · 1

Available for pickup · 1

Starlight Distillery 'Old Rickhouse' Straight Rye Whiskey

Also in our collection · 1